Pair of Linear Equations in Two Variables
1. What This Chapter Covers
The chapter opens in a book shop. Siri buys 3 notebooks and 2 pens and her father pays Rs 80. Laxmi buys 4 notebooks and 3 pens of the same kind for Rs 110. Their classmates want to know what one pen costs and what one notebook costs. Siri does not know.
That is the whole chapter in one situation. Two quantities are unknown, and no single purchase pins them down.
The index allots this chapter 15 periods in September — joint largest in the book, tied with Real Numbers. It runs from textbook page 77 to page 104, with three numbered exercises and an Optional Exercise.
2. Why One Equation Is Never Enough
Rubina guesses that a notebook costs Rs 25. Then three notebooks cost Rs 75, the two pens must make up the remaining Rs 5, and each pen is Rs 2.50. Joseph thinks Rs 2.50 is far too little for a pen; he would put it at Rs 16, which forces the notebook to Rs 16 as well.
Both guesses fit Siri's purchase exactly. Neither is obviously wrong. The textbook's point is that there are many possible pairs of prices adding to Rs 80, and Siri's situation alone cannot choose between them.
So test the guesses against Laxmi. If Rubina is right, Laxmi's 4 notebooks and 3 pens come to 4 × 25 + 3 × 2.50, which is Rs 107.50. She actually paid Rs 110. If Joseph is right, Laxmi owes 4 × 16 + 3 × 16, which is Rs 112. Also wrong.
The second purchase is what does the work. The book states the rule plainly: when we have two variables, we need at least two independent linear equations to get a unique solution.
3. The Model Method
Before any algebra, the book solves the problem by drawing. Represent a notebook by one rectangle and a pen by another, and lay out both purchases as bars.
The trick is to scale the two rows until one item appears the same number of times in both. Multiply Siri's row by 3 and Laxmi's row by 2, and each row then holds exactly 6 pens.
Nine books and six pens cost Rs 240. Eight books and six pens cost Rs 220. The pens cancel, and the single extra book accounts for the Rs 20 difference. One book is Rs 20.
Now go back to Siri: three books at Rs 20 is Rs 60, so two pens cost Rs 20 and one pen is Rs 10. Checking against Laxmi, 4 × 20 + 3 × 10 = Rs 110, which is what she paid.
The book then gives the general definition. An equation of the form ax + by + c = 0, where a, b and c are real numbers and at least one of a and b is not zero — that is, a² + b² ≠ 0 — is a linear equation in two variables x and y.
4. What a Solution Means, and the Three Pictures
A solution for a pair of linear equations is a pair of values of x and y which together satisfy each one of the equations. Not one of them; both.
The graph of a linear equation in two variables is a straight line. Points on the line are solutions of that equation; points off it are not. So a solution of the pair is a point lying on both lines at once.
That reduces the whole question to geometry. Two lines drawn in the same plane can do only three things.
The textbook attaches names to these. A pair with exactly one solution is consistent and independent. A pair with no solution is inconsistent. A pair whose lines coincide is consistent and dependent, and has infinitely many solutions.
5. The Three Cases, Each From a Real Situation
The book does not present the three cases abstractly. It draws each one from a situation already on the page.
One solution. Writing the book-shop problem with x for the cost of a notebook and y for a pen gives 3x + 2y = 80 and 4x + 3y = 110. Plotting a few points of each produces two lines that cross once.
The crossing point is (20, 10). Substituting confirms it: 3(20) + 2(10) = 80 and 4(20) + 3(10) = 110. Both equations are satisfied, so a notebook is Rs 20 and a pen Rs 10 — exactly what the model method gave.
No solution. The first Think and Discuss situation has 1 kg of potatoes and 2 kg of tomatoes costing Rs 30 one day, and 2 kg of potatoes and 4 kg of tomatoes costing Rs 66 two days later. That is x + 2y = 30 and 2x + 4y = 66.
The lines are parallel, so there is no common solution. The book reads that back into the situation rather than treating it as a failure: it means the vegetables were not the same price on the two days, which is what happens in real markets.
Infinitely many. The cricket coach buys 3 bats and 6 balls for Rs 3900, then one more bat and 2 balls for Rs 1300. These give 3x + 6y = 3900 and x + 2y = 1300. The second is the first divided by 3, so the two lines coincide, every point on one is a point on the other, and the pair has infinitely many solutions. The second purchase told us nothing the first had not.
6. Reading the Answer off the Coefficients
Drawing graphs to find out which of the three cases you are in is slow. The book's section 4.2.3 gives a test that needs no drawing at all. Write the pair as a₁x + b₁y + c₁ = 0 and a₂x + b₂y + c₂ = 0, then compare the three ratios a₁/a₂, b₁/b₂ and c₁/c₂.
Check the test against the three situations already solved. The book shop gives 3/4 and 2/3, which differ, so the lines intersect. The vegetables give 1/2, 2/4 and −30/−66; the first two agree and the third does not, so the lines are parallel. The bats and balls give 3/1, 6/2 and 3900/1300, all equal to 3, so the lines coincide.
Worth pausing on why the test works. If a₁/a₂ = b₁/b₂, the two equations have proportional left-hand sides, so the lines have the same slope. Whether they are the same line or merely parallel then depends on whether the constants keep that same proportion.
Example-1 applies the test to 2x + y − 5 = 0 and 3x − 2y − 4 = 0. Here 2/3 is not 1/(−2), so the lines intersect and the pair is consistent. Tabulating points and plotting them gives the unique solution (2, 1).
Example-2 takes 3x + 4y = 2 and 6x + 8y = 4. All three ratios equal 1/2, so the lines are coincident and the pair has infinitely many solutions. The two tables of points in the book turn out identical, which is the arithmetic saying the same thing.
Example-3 takes 2x − 3y = 5 and 4x − 6y = 15. The first two ratios are both 2/1 while the third is 3/1, so the lines are parallel and the pair is inconsistent.
7. Word Problems Answered by Drawing
Example-4 is a puzzle. In a garden there are bees and flowers. If one bee sits on each flower, one bee is left over. If two bees sit on each flower, one flower is left over. How many of each?
Let x be the bees and y the flowers. One bee per flower leaving a bee spare gives x = y + 1, which is x − y − 1 = 0. Two bees per flower leaving a flower spare means the bees fill only x/2 flowers, so y = x/2 + 1, which rearranges to x − 2y + 2 = 0.
The lines cross at (4, 3), so there are 4 bees and 3 flowers. Test it against the words rather than the algebra: one bee on each of 3 flowers uses 3 bees and leaves 1 over, and two bees per flower fills 2 flowers and leaves 1 flower empty. Both conditions hold.
Example-5 is a rectangle whose perimeter is 32 m, so l + b = 16. Increasing the length by 2 m and decreasing the breadth by 1 m leaves the area unchanged, so (l + 2)(b − 1) = lb. Expanding gives lb − l + 2b − 2 = lb, and the lb terms cancel to leave l − 2b + 2 = 0. The lines meet at (10, 6): length 10 m, breadth 6 m.
8. The Substitution Method
Graphs run out of road quickly. The book is explicit about why: the method is not convenient in all cases where the point representing the solution has no integral co-ordinates. It offers √3 and 2√7, or −1.75 and 3.3, or 4/13 and 1/19 as solutions nobody will read off graph paper correctly.
So section 4.3 turns algebraic. The first method is substitution, in five steps.
Example-6 solves 2x − y = 5 and 3x + 2y = 11. The first rearranges to y = 2x − 5. Putting that into the second gives 3x + 2(2x − 5) = 11, so 7x = 21 and x = 3. Back-substituting, 2(3) − y = 5 gives y = 1.
Step 5 is not decoration. Testing (3, 1) in the equation that was not used for back-substitution gives 3(3) + 2(1) = 11, which is correct. A slip in step 1 or 2 survives every later step and only this check catches it.
9. The Elimination Method
Elimination removes a variable by making its coefficients match, then adding or subtracting. The book's step 3 is the one students get wrong: if the variable to be eliminated has the same sign in both equations, subtract; if the signs are opposite, add.
Example-7 takes 3x + 2y = 11 and 2x + 3y = 4. The coefficients of y are 2 and 3, whose LCM is 6, so multiply the first by 3 and the second by 2. That gives 9x + 6y = 33 and 4x + 6y = 8. The y terms have the same sign, so subtract: 5x = 25 and x = 5. Then 3(5) + 2y = 11 gives y = −2.
Example-8 does one problem by both methods so they can be compared. Rubina withdraws Rs 2000 in Rs 50 and Rs 100 notes and receives 25 notes in all. With x fifty-rupee notes and y hundred-rupee notes, x + y = 25 and 50x + 100y = 2000. Both routes give ten Rs 50 notes and fifteen Rs 100 notes.
Example-9 is a competitive exam. Three marks per correct answer and one deducted per wrong answer gave Madhu 40 marks; four per correct and two deducted would have given 50. With x correct and y wrong, 3x − y = 40 and 4x − 2y = 50, which solve to x = 15 and y = 5, so the test had 20 questions.
Example-10 is an age problem. Mary tells her daughter that seven years ago she was seven times as old, and that three years from now she will be three times as old.
From x − 7 = 7(y − 7) and x + 3 = 3(y + 3) come x − 7y + 42 = 0 and x − 3y − 6 = 0, giving Mary 42 and her daughter 12. Seven years back that is 35 and 5; three years on it is 45 and 15.
Example-11 is a break-even calculation. A publisher spends Rs 320000 in fixed costs plus Rs 31.25 a book, and receives Rs 43.75 a book. Setting 43.75x = 320000 + 31.25x leaves 12.5x = 320000, so the publisher breaks even at 25,600 books.
10. Equations That Are Not Linear Until You Rewrite Them
Section 4.4 handles pairs that are not linear as written but become linear after a substitution. The move is always the same: name the awkward block as a new variable.
Example-12 takes 2/x + 3/y = 13 and 5/x − 4/y = −2. These are not linear in x and y. But putting p = 1/x and q = 1/y turns them into 2p + 3q = 13 and 5p − 4q = −2, which are linear. Eliminating q gives 23p = 46, so p = 2 and q = 3, and therefore x = 1/2 and y = 1/3.
The last step is the one people forget. Solving for p and q is not solving for x and y; you must undo the substitution.
Example-13 is a work-rate problem. Six men and eight women finish a job in 14 days, and eight men and twelve women finish it in 10 days. Let x be the days one man alone would take and y the days one woman would take, so one man does 1/x of the work a day and one woman 1/y.
Ten days of eight men and twelve women completes the job, giving 80/x + 120/y = 1. Fourteen days of six men and eight women gives 84/x + 112/y = 1. Substituting u = 1/x and v = 1/y and eliminating gives 280v = 1, so v = 1/280 and u = 1/140. One man alone takes 140 days and one woman alone 280 days.
Example-14 mixes two speeds. A man covers 370 km partly by train and partly by car. Doing 250 km by train takes 4 hours in all; doing 130 km by train takes 18 minutes longer. With x the train's speed and y the car's, time equals distance over speed, so 250/x + 120/y = 4 and 130/x + 240/y = 43/10.
Substituting a = 1/x and b = 1/y gives 125a + 60b = 2 and 130a + 240b = 43/10. Eliminating b leaves 370a = 37/10, so a = 1/100 and b = 1/80. The train does 100 km/h and the car 80 km/h, which checks: 250/100 + 120/80 = 4 hours exactly.
11. What the Exercises Ask, and Where the Book's Answers Go Wrong
Exercise 4.1 has nine questions: three ratio classifications, nine consistency checks with graphs, and six word problems on pants and skirts, a quiz, pencils and pens, a garden, building a pair with a chosen relationship, and a rectangle's area. Exercise 4.2 has ten word problems. Exercise 4.3 has eight reducible pairs and three word problems, and the Optional Exercise adds six more pairs and a diet-mixture problem.
Answers for all three are printed at textbook pages 375 and 376. Every one of the eight answers to Exercise 4.3 question 1 is correct, as are all ten of Exercise 4.2 except one part. But three printed answers are wrong, and each is worth knowing before you use the key.
Exercise 4.1 question 2(f) gives x + y = 5 and 2x + 2y = 10, and the key answers "Inconsistent". Compare the ratios: 1/2, 1/2 and 5/10, which is 1/2. All three are equal, so by the book's own rule on page 104 the lines coincide. The pair is consistent and dependent with infinitely many solutions. The second equation is simply the first doubled.
Exercise 4.2 question 4(ii) is the Hyderabad taxi. A fixed charge covers the first 3 km and a per-kilometre rate applies beyond it; 10 km costs Rs 166 and 15 km costs Rs 256. The key's own first answer is right: 5 extra kilometres cost Rs 90, so the rate is Rs 18 and the fixed charge is 166 − 7(18) = Rs 40.
But it then prints Rs 490 for a 25 km journey. That is 40 + 25(18), which charges the first 3 km twice. A 25 km trip is 40 + 22(18) = Rs 436.
Exercise 4.3 question 2(iii) asks how long one woman and one man each take on an embroidery job, given that 2 women and 5 men finish in 4 days and 3 women and 6 men finish in 3 days. The key prints "man = 18, woman = 36", and the labels are swapped.
With a woman at 18 days and a man at 36, two women and five men do 2/18 + 5/36 = 1/4 of the job a day, which is the 4 days required. The key's labelling gives 1/3 and fails the condition it was built from.
There is also a wording slip in the key for question 3 of Exercise 4.1, which reports "Number of shirts = 0" for a question about skirts. The number is right.
Four things in the chapter text itself are worth flagging. The graph on page 87 illustrating Example-3 is labelled 4x − 6y = 9, but the line drawn is the right one for Example-3's 4x − 6y = 15 — it crosses the y-axis at −2.5 and carries the plotted points (0, −2.5), (3, −0.5) and (6, 1.5) straight from the table above it. Only the label is wrong.
Question 5 of the Do This box on page 92 prints 0.2x + 0.3y = 13 alongside 0.4x + 0.5y = 2.3. A decimal point has been dropped: with 1.3 the pair solves cleanly to x = 2 and y = 3, while with 13 it gives x = −290.5 and y = 237.
On page 99, inside Example-13, the line "the portion of work done by 8 women in one day is 8 × 1/x" should say 8 men, since 1/x was defined three lines earlier as one man's daily share. The algebra that follows is correct; only the words are wrong. Finally, the section numbering jumps from 4.2.1 straight to 4.2.3, with no 4.2.2 anywhere in the chapter.
12. Summary
Two unknowns need two independent equations. One equation in two variables has infinitely many solutions, so a single purchase, a single measurement or a single clue can never fix both quantities.
A pair of linear equations is two lines, and a solution is a point on both. Two lines can intersect once, run parallel, or coincide — giving one solution, none, or infinitely many, and named consistent and independent, inconsistent, and consistent and dependent.
The ratios of the coefficients settle which case applies without any drawing. If a₁/a₂ ≠ b₁/b₂ there is one solution; if the first two ratios agree but c₁/c₂ differs there is none; if all three agree there are infinitely many.
Graphs are honest but imprecise, so the chapter supplies two algebraic methods. Substitution writes one variable in terms of the other and reduces the pair to a single equation. Elimination matches a coefficient and then adds or subtracts, subtracting when the signs agree.
Pairs that are not linear can often be made linear by naming the awkward block. Setting 1/x = p, or 1/(x + y) = p, converts reciprocal, speed, work and mixture problems into ordinary pairs — provided you remember to convert back at the end.
