Environment, Sustainable Development, and Comparative Development Experiences — Practice

Question 1

What is sustainable development? State the Brundtland definition and explain any TWO principles.

Accepted Answer

SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT: Development that meets present needs without compromising future generations' ability to meet their own needs (Brundtland Commission, 1987). It balances three pillars: economic growth + social equity + environmental protection. PRINCIPLE 1 — INTERGENERATIONAL EQUITY: The current generation must not deplete natural resources (forests, groundwater, biodiversity) or damage the environment (climate, oceans) to a point that future generations are unable to meet their needs. Example: Extracting groundwater faster than it recharges = robbing future farmers of water. Intergenerational equity demands we leave nature in at least as good a condition as we found it. PRINCIPLE 2 — POLLUTER PAYS PRINCIPLE: Those who cause pollution must BEAR ITS COSTS — rather than passing these costs to society (through public health burden, cleanup costs, reduced quality of life). Example: A factory that pollutes a river must pay for the cleanup and compensate affected communities — not externalize these costs to the public. This aligns private incentives with social welfare.

Question 2

Compare the development experiences of India, China, and Pakistan since independence. What explains the differences?

Accepted Answer

CHINA'S RAPID DEVELOPMENT: China launched its economic reforms in 1978 under Deng Xiaoping — 13 years before India. China's strategy: EXPORT-LED MANUFACTURING. China became the 'world's factory' — cheap labour, government infrastructure investment, and export orientation drove 10%+ annual growth for three decades. Result: GDP grew from ~$150B (1978) to $18+ trillion (2024). Poverty reduction: extraordinary — 800+ million lifted from extreme poverty since 1980 (the largest poverty reduction in human history). Human development: literacy 97%, life expectancy 78 years, HDI 0.768. Political system: one-party communist state — allowed rapid decision-making but with severe human rights costs. INDIA'S GRADUAL DEVELOPMENT: India reformed in 1991, 13 years after China. India chose SERVICES-LED growth (IT, finance, telecommunications) rather than manufacturing. Growth accelerated to 6-8% post-1991 but remained below China's manufacturing-driven rates. Poverty fell significantly but more slowly. Human development: literacy 78%, life expectancy 70 years, HDI 0.633. Political system: Democracy — slower decisions but more political freedom and stability. PAKISTAN'S UNDERPERFORMANCE: Despite similar starting conditions to India in 1947, Pakistan has substantially underperformed. GDP growth: volatile, averaging 3-4% (vs India's ~6-7%). Literacy ~60% (vs India's 78%). HDI 0.544 (vs India's 0.633). REASONS: (1) Political instability — frequent military coups interrupted democratic governance and long-term planning. (2) Inconsistent economic policy — each government reversed previous government's initiatives. (3) Military spending: Pakistan spends ~4% of GDP on defence (vs India's ~2.5%), crowding out education, health, and infrastructure. (4) Terrorism and security concerns: have deterred foreign investment. KEY LESSONS: China shows what FAST GROWTH looks like without democracy — possible but at political cost. India shows DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT — slower but more participatory. Pakistan shows the cost of POLITICAL INSTABILITY — consistent policy is necessary for sustained development.

Question 3

Why is environment considered an important dimension of development in India? What environmental challenges does India face, and what is India's approach to sustainable development?

Accepted Answer

WHY ENVIRONMENT IS A DEVELOPMENT DIMENSION: Traditional development thinking measured progress solely through GDP growth. But the Brundtland Commission (1987) established that ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH is a precondition for sustainable development — because the economy ultimately depends on nature for resources (land, water, energy, materials) and services (climate regulation, water purification, biodiversity). A country can appear to grow rapidly while depleting its natural capital — and eventually collapse when that capital is exhausted. For India, with 1.4 billion people depending on agriculture, monsoons, and natural resources, environmental degradation is not a distant threat — it is an immediate development emergency. INDIA'S ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGES: (1) AIR POLLUTION: India has many of the world's most polluted cities. Delhi's PM2.5 levels regularly exceed WHO safe limits by 10-20 times. The health cost: 1.6 million premature deaths per year in India attributable to air pollution (Lancet study). Sources: vehicles, coal power plants, stubble burning (Punjab/Haryana farmers burning rice straw), construction, and industrial emissions. The National Clean Air Programme (NCAP) targets 20-30% reduction in particulate pollution. (2) WATER STRESS: India is home to 18% of the world's population but only 4% of global fresh water. 70% of surface water is polluted. 91 of India's 100 largest cities face water scarcity. The Ganga — sacred to 500 million Hindus — carries heavy industrial and municipal effluents despite the Namami Gange programme (₹20,000 crore). Most critically: GROUNDWATER DEPLETION. Punjab and Haryana (the Green Revolution heartland) are extracting groundwater 2-3 times the recharge rate — the water table is falling by 0.5-1 metre per year. This is the Green Revolution's hidden cost coming due. (3) LAND DEGRADATION: ~30% of India's land (98 million hectares) is degraded from deforestation, soil erosion, salinisation from over-irrigation, and chemical overuse. India committed to LAND DEGRADATION NEUTRALITY by 2030 under the UNCCD framework. (4) CLIMATE VULNERABILITY: India contributes ~7% of global CO₂ emissions (3rd largest globally) but bears disproportionate climate impacts: melting Himalayan glaciers threaten the water security of 700 million people. Sea level rise threatens 150+ million coastal residents. Increased extreme heat events and erratic monsoons threaten agriculture. (5) FOREST LOSS: India has reversed some historical deforestation (forest cover now ~24% of land area, near 33% target of the National Forest Policy) but forest quality and biodiversity are declining. INDIA'S APPROACH TO SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT: India has adopted a two-track approach: MITIGATION: (1) Net Zero by 2070 (COP26, Glasgow, 2021 commitment). (2) 500 GW renewable energy by 2030 — currently on track with ~200 GW installed (2024). (3) 45% reduction in GDP emissions intensity from 2005 levels by 2030. (4) 50% non-fossil energy by 2030. (5) International Solar Alliance (ISA) — India's initiative to bring together 120+ sunshine-rich developing countries to accelerate solar deployment. ADAPTATION: (1) National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC, 2008): 8 national missions including National Solar Mission, National Water Mission, National Mission for Sustainable Agriculture. (2) Coastal protection, early warning systems for cyclones, drought-resistant crop development. INDIA'S DIPLOMATIC POSITION: India consistently emphasises COMMON BUT DIFFERENTIATED RESPONSIBILITIES (CBDR) — developed nations caused most historical emissions and must cut fastest. India has the right to develop. Per capita emissions (~2 tonnes CO₂) are far below USA (~14) or EU (~7). India argues for climate finance and technology transfer from rich nations to support the green transition. CONCLUSION: India's development challenge is to grow its economy rapidly (to lift remaining millions from poverty), while transitioning to clean energy and sustainable resource use. This is genuinely difficult — no large country has done it before. India's trajectory on renewables (world's largest solar expansion), on Ayushman Bharat (healthcare), on digital infrastructure (UPI), suggests it is finding innovative paths to sustainable development. The next 20 years will determine whether India succeeds.

Practice — Environment, Sustainable Development, and Comparative Development Experiences

Sign in to save attempts to your dashboard and track your accuracy over time

Find a verified tutor

Join a live course

Browse coaching centres

About

Categories

Support

Documentation

Get Study Tips & Updates

Download Our App

Download for iOS

Download for Android

Popular Cities