A steel wire of length 4.7 m and cross-sectional area 3.0 × 10⁻⁵ m² stretches by the same amount as a copper wire of length 3.5 m and cross-sectional area of 4.0 × 10⁻⁵ m² under a given load. What is the ratio of the Young's modulus of steel to that of copper?
Hint. Write Y = FL/(A·ΔL) for each wire separately, then divide one by the other. The load and the stretch are the same for both, so those two symbols will cancel — you never need their numerical values.
Step 1 — Write Young's modulus for each wire. From the definition Y = stress/strain = (F/A)/(ΔL/L), rearranging gives
Y = FL/(A·ΔL)
For steel: Y_s = F·L_s/(A_s·ΔL_s) For copper: Y_c = F·L_c/(A_c·ΔL_c)
Step 2 — Use what the question tells you is shared. The phrase "under a given load" means the same force F acts on both, and "stretches by the same amount" means ΔL_s = ΔL_c. So both F and ΔL are common to the two wires, which is why they will cancel in the ratio and why the question never gives you their values.
Step 3 — Take the ratio. Y_s/Y_c = [F·L_s/(A_s·ΔL)] ÷ [F·L_c/(A_c·ΔL)]
Cancelling F and ΔL:
Y_s/Y_c = (L_s/A_s) × (A_c/L_c) = (L_s × A_c)/(A_s × L_c)
Step 4 — Substitute the numbers. Y_s/Y_c = (4.7 × 4.0 × 10⁻⁵)/(3.0 × 10⁻⁵ × 3.5) = (1.88 × 10⁻⁴)/(1.05 × 10⁻⁴) = 1.79
Step 5 — Sanity check against Table 8.1. The table gives Y_steel = 200 × 10⁹ Pa and Y_copper = 110 × 10⁹ Pa, a ratio of 1.82. Our answer of 1.79 sits right on top of that, so the working is sound.
✦ Y_steel : Y_copper ≈ 1.8 : 1 — steel is about 1.8 times as stiff as copper.
Where students slip. Inverting the area ratio. Since Y = FL/(A·ΔL), the area sits in the denominator, so the copper area A_c must end up on top when you form Y_s/Y_c. Writing (L_s/L_c)×(A_s/A_c) gives 1.01 instead of 1.79 — a suspiciously round answer that should make you re-check.
