Consider the reaction A + B → C. Assume A and B cannot be broken down into simpler substances by chemical reactions. Which statement is correct? (i) A, B and C are all compounds and only C has a fixed composition. (ii) C is a compound, and A and B have a fixed composition. (iii) A and B are compounds, and C has a fixed composition. (iv) A and B are elements, C is a compound, and has a fixed composition.
Hint. The condition given about A and B is the definition of one particular category.
Answer: (iv) A and B are elements, C is a compound, and has a fixed composition.
Step by step.
- A and B cannot be broken down into simpler substances — that is exactly the chapter's definition of an element. So A and B are elements.
- C is formed when two different elements combine chemically. Compounds are formed when different elements combine in fixed ratios to form something entirely new. So C is a compound.
- And in fixed ratios is part of that same definition, so C has a fixed composition.
✦ Why each of the others fails:
| Option | Fault |
|---|---|
| (i) | Calls A and B compounds, which contradicts the condition that they cannot be broken down |
| (ii) | Right about C, but 'A and B have a fixed composition' is the wrong claim — an element has no composition to fix, being one kind of atom |
| (iii) | Again calls A and B compounds, contradicting the given condition |
The single line to write in an exam: A and B cannot be broken down, so they are elements; C is formed by their chemical combination, so it is a compound with a fixed composition.
