Which of the statements about the reaction below are incorrect? 2PbO(s) + C(s) → 2Pb(s) + CO₂(g) (a) Lead is getting reduced. (b) Carbon dioxide is getting oxidised. (c) Carbon is getting oxidised. (d) Lead oxide is getting reduced. (i) (a) and (b) (ii) (a) and (c) (iii) (a), (b) and (c) (iv) all
Hint. Notice that (a) and (d) look like they're saying the same thing — one names the element, the other names the compound. Only one of those two phrasings is chemically precise here.
Step 1 — Track what happens to lead and carbon. Lead goes from PbO to Pb — it loses oxygen, i.e. lead oxide is reduced to lead. Carbon goes from C to CO₂ — it gains oxygen, i.e. carbon is oxidised.
Step 2 — Check each statement against this. (a) 'Lead is getting reduced' — imprecise, since it is the compound lead oxide that loses oxygen and is reduced, not the element 'lead' (which isn't a separate reactant here to be reduced from anything) — INCORRECT as worded. (b) 'Carbon dioxide is getting oxidised' — CO₂ is the product already formed by carbon's oxidation; it is not itself undergoing any further oxidation — INCORRECT. (c) 'Carbon is getting oxidised' — matches Step 1 exactly — CORRECT. (d) 'Lead oxide is getting reduced' — matches Step 1 exactly — CORRECT.
Step 3 — Match to the options. The incorrect statements are (a) and (b), which is option (i).
✦ Answer: (i) (a) and (b).
Where students slip. Picking (ii) or (iii) by assuming (c) must also be wrong because it looks similar to (b) — but (c) talks about carbon, the element actually being oxidised, while (b) talks about carbon dioxide, the already-oxidised product. That mismatch is the deliberate trap in this question.
