Megha's and Pawan's bags are equally heavy, yet Pawan's hurts his shoulders and Megha's does not. Explain why.
Hint. Pawan works it out himself in the story. Look at the straps.
Because of the width of the straps. Pawan says it himself: My bag has narrow straps while your bag has broad straps.
The explanation. When we carry a bag, we feel its weight because of the force of gravity acting on our shoulders. The weight of the bag with narrow straps acts on a smaller area of our shoulders, whereas the weight of the bag with broad straps is spread out over a larger area.
| Pawan's bag | Megha's bag | |
|---|---|---|
| Weight of the bag | The same | The same |
| Area of shoulder it acts on | Small (narrow straps) | Large (broad straps) |
| Force per unit area | High | Low |
| How it feels | Hurts | Comfortable |
✦ Why this story is where the chapter begins. It isolates the new idea perfectly. The force is identical in the two cases — the bags are equally heavy — so whatever makes the difference cannot be the force. Only the area has changed. That forces you to invent a quantity that involves both, which is exactly what the next paragraph does:
Since the area over which the force acts is involved, we define a quantity called pressure, which is the force per unit area.
Broad straps do not reduce the weight — they reduce the pressure. Keeping those two apart is the whole point of the chapter's first section.
